Public Television’s Flagship Station Undermines Good Music

This evening I will be attending the post-gala opening concert of the New York Philharmonic’s “official” season (which I am reviewing for ClassicalSource.com).

In preparation for tonight’s concert, I decided to tune in last night’s broadcast of the Philharmonic’s opening gala on thirteen (WNET-HD, Channel 13 in New York City) via my Time Warner HD cable feed.

Am I the only person who found it infuriating that the video feed was a (poorly) upsampled standard-definition signal?

Worse yet, the audio quality was an embarrassment: radically compressed dynamic range, aggressive employment of limiters that introduced a “breathing effect,” and an ugly string timbre that bore no resemblance to Philharmonic.

But it came as no surprise. Last night’s botch job was typical of the poor quality thirteen has been foisting on viewers as “quality programming” for well over a decade.

Memo to PBS: if you’re going to broadcast or videotape a Lincoln Center event, at least spring for the gear to give us a real HD signal. And I’ll be the first to admit that Avery Fisher Hall is nightmare audio recording/broadcast venue, but there is NO excuse for crappy sound. I have not seen any Live from Lincoln Center events outside of New York City on a decent home theater system, so I can’t be certain as to which knob-twiddler(s) in the audio chain might be the culprit(s) — PBS’s remote team, thirteen, or Time Warner — but I would venture a guess that no one is innocent, but some are more guilty than others.

So here’s a little unsolicited advice for all concerned: fix it. And here’s some news for PBS and thirteen: music lovers DO have the brains to lower the volume before the music begins so that something resembling a realistic dynamic range eMerges from their speaker(s). Maybe you should send your broadcast producers and engineers to NHK in Japan or BR and WDR in Germany to see and hear televised classical music done right. Something has to be done, because the present status quo is not only an insult to your viewers but the music and artists.

Leave a Reply